[hpsdr] To kit or not to kit...............

[Eric Ellison]

Steve


In talking with Phil_H - VK6APH and Bill - KD5TFD on Teamspeak the past 2
weeks, (I have not polled Phil_C) both feel that we won't need a Beta on the
Janus or Ozy. There have been very few, 'jumpers' needed on either board,
and the corrections are minor. Phil thinks we can go to production from the
5 alphas. That should make the three hundred+ folks wanting Janus/Ozy happy.


One of the nice things about this Reflector/Group, is that people have just
'jumped in' (and a couple 'jumped out') and has formed a pretty good
'pick-up' team effort. We've had a 'lot of eyes' reviewing designs,
schematics, circuit boards etc, which really heads off mistakes and
generates great ideas. Horst has had assembly manuals before the alpha tests
were even over, Atlas is now in 5 languages, and I feel Horst and crew will
have Pinocchio, Janus and Ozy translated in short order. Lurkers have been
particularly helpful jumping in with help on occasion, without having to
commit to more than suggestions. Bill and Phil meet on Teamspeak usually 2
times daily to discuss progress and coordinate. The Wiki, Website, SVN are
all alive and well and giving us excellent tools for review and rapid
progress. Just the dynamics of this group is exciting! 

I guess the first poll question should be should we delay production
Janus/Ozy by 3 months or so, or take the personal risk (as we did with
Atlas/Pinocchio) and have something to use?

Conventional wisdom would be to go the beta, however, we have some
astoundingly unconventional and truly gifted folk here! (smile).

>From a personal standpoint, I'm willing to risk my money on these designs,
even if they need a couple of 'yellow wires'.

Just my 2 cents.
Eric










-----Original Message-----
From: hpsdr-bounces at hpsdr.org [mailto:hpsdr-bounces at hpsdr.org] On Behalf Of
Steven Bible
Sent: Saturday, July 22, 2006 11:26 PM
To: hpsdr at hpsdr.org
Subject: Re: [hpsdr] To kit or not to kit...............

***** High Performance Software Defined Radio Discussion List *****

Gang,

This has all been a very interesting discussion.  We have people of all
talents and skill levels.  Remember the idea of a farmers co-op?  From the
Wikipedia:

  A cooperative (also co-operative or co-op) is a group
  of persons who join together or co-operate, to carry
  on an economic activity of mutual benefit.

May I make a recommendation, we need to identify all the roles needed to
take a project from idea to delivered hardware.  As Bob has pointed out, we
are still in the early development/prototyping phase (we are slightly past
the research phase).  We still need skills and labor that will take the
finished prototypes and deliver hardware.  What are these phases?

I suggest that next after the prototypes are finalized that we enter a beta
phase.  Those folks who have the skills to hand build the boards are great
candidates for this phase.  Their desires is to hand build and learn from
the building.  From their experiences, the final boards are evolved.  Then
on to the next phase.

This phase is the contract manufacturing stage.  We can go about this a
couple of different ways.  The easiest is that we hand over a bill of
materials, Gerber files, and test plan.  What we get out of it are assembled
and tested boards.  This option has some expense only if the numbers are
low.  The other way is buying the parts and handing them to a contract
manufacturer.  Thought some contract manufacturers like this option as they
need the parts packaged in such a way that they can do machine assembly
(tape and reel, tubes, etc.).  We need people who are familiar with this
phase, who have worked with contract manufacturers.  We need people to
recommend their favorite contract manufacturer.

We need people to chronical the process from idea to operations manual.  We
need people to count money.  We need parts buyers for the prototypes and
betas.  We need people to put beta kits together.  (what other roles can you
think of?)

If we could identify and gently formalize what the phases are, what roles
are needed, who the names of the people that will fill those roles, as the
product evolves, it gets handed to the next people in the process.  Then we
are well on our way to a finished product.

73,

- Steve, N7HPR
 (n7hpr at tapr.org)


_______________________________________________
HPSDR Discussion List
To post msg: hpsdr at hpsdr.org
Subscription help: http://lists.hpsdr.org/listinfo.cgi/hpsdr-hpsdr.org
HPSDR web page: http://hpsdr.org
Archives: http://lists.hpsdr.org/pipermail/hpsdr-hpsdr.org/


 1153629981.0