[hpsdr] "FPGA Floor Planning"

[Bryan Rambo]

Hi Joe,

Thanks to you (and George too) for helping me understand!
I guess my idea was pretty naive!
DFC, with its small FPGA footprint, is now looking better and better to me
:-)

73, Bryan W4WMT


-----Original Message-----
From: Joe Martin [mailto:k5so at k5so.com] 
Sent: Friday, February 10, 2017 10:46 AM
To: bryanr at bometals.com
Cc: OpenHPSDR
Subject: Re: [hpsdr] "FPGA Floor Planning"

Hi Bryan, 

There are several ways that paid subscriptions could be paid for, of course.
I do appreciate your willingness to contribute but if we begin to utilize
paid subscriptions then others who might be willing to get their feet wet
with FPGA programming in the openHPSDR community would not have access to
those subscriptions so it hardly seems appropriate to have a select few to
have the paid tools in such a project.  Further, as for me personally and I
believe Phil feels similarly, we really do not wish to embark on a new
career in FPGA programming, this is a hobby after all, and having others pay
for fancy tools for us would put an undue guilt trip on us if we wish to, or
at some point decide to, put less time in on this "hobby" project.  

We have demonstrated that what needs to be done can in fact be done using
the free tools, albeit with some effort.  

Hope that helps you understand better the situation.  Thanks again though!

73, Joe K5SO

> On Feb 10, 2017, at 8:12 AM, Bryan Rambo <bryanr at bometals.com> wrote:
> 
> ***** High Performance Software Defined Radio Discussion List *****
> 
> Hi Joe (and Phil perhaps?),
> 
> Would crowdfunding a paid Quartus subscription for our developers to use
be
> inconsistent with the "open" in OpenHPSDR?  If not, you can count on me
for
> a generous contribution.
> 
> I pose this as a question, rather than as an assertion, because I truly
> don't understand the ramifications of these GNU style open-source
licensing
> arrangements.
> 
> 73, Bryan W4WMT